Aller au contenu principal

Audit Report

Date: 2026-02-12 22:45 Project: Good Vibe Coding Website Status: WARN (improved from FAIL) Audit mode: --fix autonomous (3 iterations)

Before / After Summary​

#CategoryBeforeAfterDelta
1Tests3/1003/100-
2Code Quality (Lint/Format/Types)20/10030/100+10
3Security78/10088/100+10
4Dependencies70/10080/100+10
5Performance65/10065/100-
6Code Duplication20/10020/100-
7Code Smells30/10040/100+10
8Architecture Compliance70/10085/100+15
9Design/UI52/10062/100+10
10i18n50/10050/100-
11Documentation50/10080/100+30
12SEO40/10075/100+35
13Environment60/10085/100+25
14API ComplianceN/AN/A-
15CI/CD Pipeline70/10070/100-
16Legal Compliance10/10065/100+55
17MetricsN/AN/A-
18Git Hygiene60/10070/100+10
19Logging & Observability40/10042/100+2
20Docker60/10080/100+20
21Testing Quality3/1003/100-

Score global: ~43/100 -> ~58/100 (+15 points) - WARN

Total: 87 issues -> ~45 issues (48% resolved) Iterations: 3 (2 with fixes, 1 assessment-only) Commits: 2

Fixes Applied (Iterations 1-2)​

Iteration 1 (22 files, 761 insertions, 121 deletions)​

CategoryFixImpact
SEORemoved noindex, nofollow meta robotsCRITICAL - site now indexable
SEOFixed robots.txt: Disallow: / -> Allow: / with SitemapCRITICAL
LegalCreated /mentions-legales pageCRITICAL - French law compliance
LegalCreated /politique-de-confidentialite page (RGPD)CRITICAL
LegalAdded "Legal" footer column with linksCRITICAL
Securitynpm audit fix (qs vulnerability patched)HIGH
SecurityAdded CSP, HSTS, Referrer-Policy, Permissions-Policy to render.yamlMEDIUM
SecurityAdded security headers to nginx.confMEDIUM
Dead codeRemoved HomepageFeatures component (unused)MEDIUM
Dead codeRemoved 3 unused animation variants (fadeIn, slideInLeft, slideInRight)LOW
Dead codeRemoved useBaseUrl dead imports from 5 pagesLOW
DependenciesMoved remotion/player/cli to devDependenciesLOW
DockerAdded HEALTHCHECK instructionMEDIUM
DockerAdded non-root user setup (appgroup/appuser)MEDIUM
DockerImproved .dockerignoreLOW
EnvironmentCreated .env.exampleLOW
GitAdded .env and bundle-report.html to .gitignoreLOW
DocumentationUpdated CLAUDE.md (all 16 pages, components, data, Remotion)MEDIUM

Iteration 2 (2 files, 35 insertions, 11 deletions)​

CategoryFixImpact
AccessibilityAdded 20+ aria-label attributes to form inputsHIGH
AccessibilityAdded role="form", role="radiogroup", role="group"HIGH
AccessibilityAdded role="progressbar" with aria-valuenow/min/maxMEDIUM
Code smellFixed non-awaited fetch() in form handlerMEDIUM
Code smellRemoved mode: 'no-cors' for proper error handlingMEDIUM
Code smellRemoved stray console.log from service workerLOW

Remaining Issues (manual intervention needed)​

Critical - None remaining​

High Priority​

#IssueEffortSuggested command
1Zero tests - no framework, no coverageLarge/gvc improve testing
2Code duplication - 4 industry pages ~2,200 lines identicalLarge/gvc improve duplication
3ESLint + Prettier - no linting configuredMedium/gvc improve lint
4GSAP lazy loading - LazyGSAP hook exists but unusedMedium/gvc improve perf

Medium Priority​

#IssueEffortSuggested command
5Homepage SEO - missing Head, canonical URL, JSON-LDMedium/gvc improve seo
6Cookie banner - missing consent mechanismMedium/gvc improve legal
7Analytics - no Plausible/MatomoSmall/gvc improve logging
8Error boundaries - no React Error BoundarySmall/gvc improve design
9audit-sprint.js - 923 lines, 22 useState, needs decompositionLarge/gvc improve smells
10Inline styles - 253 instances across 15 filesLarge/gvc improve design
11npm vulns - 2 HIGH in sharp-cli (devDep, needs breaking change)MediumManual
12prefers-reduced-motion - animations not disabledSmall/gvc improve design

Low Priority​

#IssueEffort
13Outdated packages (5 minor/patch updates)
14Git LFS for video files
15Husky + commitlint setup
16CI/CD: add lint/test/audit steps
17CI/CD: pin GitHub Actions to SHA
18Hardcoded colors in CSS (~100+)
19English remnants in alt text
20Multiple h1 tags in vibes-selection.js
21GSAP/Remotion license verification

Phase Details​

Phase 1: Tests - 3/100 (unchanged)​

  • No test framework, no test files, no coverage
  • Requires: install Vitest, write tests for utils/data/hooks/form

Phase 2: Code Quality - 30/100 (was 20)​

  • Fixed: dead imports removed (5 files)
  • Fixed: unused components/variants removed
  • Remaining: no ESLint, no Prettier, no TypeScript

Phase 3: Security - 88/100 (was 78)​

  • Fixed: qs vulnerability patched via npm audit fix
  • Fixed: CSP, HSTS, Referrer-Policy, Permissions-Policy added
  • Fixed: mode: 'no-cors' removed from fetch
  • Remaining: 2 HIGH in sharp-cli (devDep only), webhook URL exposed client-side

Phase 4: Dependencies - 80/100 (was 70)​

  • Fixed: remotion deps moved to devDependencies
  • Remaining: 5 outdated packages (minor), license verification needed

Phase 5: Performance - 65/100 (unchanged)​

  • Remaining: LazyGSAP unused, static framer-motion imports

Phase 6: Code Duplication - 20/100 (unchanged)​

  • Remaining: ~2,930 duplicated lines across industry pages

Phase 7: Code Smells - 40/100 (was 30)​

  • Fixed: non-awaited fetch, mode: 'no-cors', console.log
  • Remaining: long files (6 files >400 lines), inline styles, magic strings

Phase 8: Architecture - 85/100 (was 70)​

  • Fixed: dead code removed (HomepageFeatures, unused variants)
  • Fixed: documentation updated
  • Remaining: landing pages define local fadeIn instead of importing

Phase 9: Design/UI - 62/100 (was 52)​

  • Fixed: 20+ aria-labels, roles, progressbar accessibility
  • Remaining: hardcoded colors, prefers-reduced-motion, mobile overflow

Phase 10: i18n - 50/100 (unchanged)​

  • French-only site, no i18n infrastructure
  • Remaining: English remnants, hardcoded strings

Phase 11: Documentation - 80/100 (was 50)​

  • Fixed: CLAUDE.md updated with all 16 pages, components, data, Remotion
  • Remaining: README.md still boilerplate, DEPLOY_STATIC.md outdated

Phase 12: SEO - 75/100 (was 40)​

  • Fixed: noindex/nofollow removed (CRITICAL)
  • Fixed: robots.txt allows crawling with Sitemap
  • Remaining: homepage missing JSON-LD, canonical URL, Head component

Phase 13: Environment - 85/100 (was 60)​

  • Fixed: .env.example created
  • Fixed: .gitignore covers .env
  • Remaining: minor

Phase 14: API Compliance - N/A​

  • Static site, no API endpoints

Phase 15: CI/CD - 70/100 (unchanged)​

  • Remaining: no lint/test/audit in CI, actions not pinned to SHA

Phase 16: Legal - 65/100 (was 10)​

  • Fixed: mentions-legales page created
  • Fixed: politique-de-confidentialite page created
  • Fixed: legal footer links added
  • Remaining: cookie banner, CGU/CGV, SIRET/RCS to fill in, form consent checkbox

Phase 17: Metrics - N/A​

  • 28 JS files, ~16.5k LOC, 10+10 deps

Phase 18: Git Hygiene - 70/100 (was 60)​

  • Fixed: .gitignore improved
  • Remaining: no pre-commit hooks, large files without LFS, mixed conventions

Phase 19: Logging - 42/100 (was 40)​

  • Fixed: stray console.log removed
  • Remaining: no analytics, no error tracking, no error boundaries

Phase 20: Docker - 80/100 (was 60)​

  • Fixed: HEALTHCHECK added
  • Fixed: non-root user created
  • Fixed: security headers in nginx.conf
  • Fixed: .dockerignore improved
  • Remaining: nginx still runs as root (port 80 binding)

Phase 21: Testing Quality - 3/100 (unchanged)​

  • No test framework installed, 0 tests

Next Steps​

# High priority (remaining issues):
/gvc improve testing      # Install Vitest + write tests
/gvc improve duplication  # Extract IndustryPage template component
/gvc improve lint         # Configure ESLint + Prettier + Husky
/gvc improve perf         # Activate LazyGSAP, lazy framer-motion

# Medium priority:
/gvc improve seo          # Homepage JSON-LD + canonical
/gvc improve legal        # Cookie banner + CGU + fill SIRET
/gvc improve logging      # Add Plausible analytics
/gvc improve design       # Error boundaries + prefers-reduced-motion
/gvc improve smells       # Decompose audit-sprint.js